Tuning Wiki

This is a historical revision. Read the current page or return to its history.

Page organisation in this revision
Page type
Technical article
Subject
Gearboxes
Parent
Section level
Applies to
No ECU-specific applicability
Tool groups
None
Manufacturers
BMW

BMW used the SMG name for more than one automated manual gearbox. This guide is specific to the E46 M3 SMG II described in BMW's training manual: a Getrag S6S420G six-speed manual-type gearbox, a single dry self-adjusting clutch and electronically controlled electrohydraulic actuators. It does not provide diagnosis or pressure limits for every SMG, ZF SMG, SMG III or dual-clutch BMW. Identify the VIN, model, gearbox, control-unit and software versions before using any procedure. BMW E46 M complete vehicle training manual, SMG II chapter (manufacturer document hosted by NAM3Forum; also checked against the supplied BMW ST041 and ST043 SMG II manuals).

For the later and mechanically different E60 M5 system, see BMW SMG III operation and diagnosis.

Other E46 installations use different transmissions: see BMW E46 torque-converter automatic gearbox identification.

How this system works

The driver requests a gear with the lever or paddles in sequential mode, or selects automatic mode. The SMG II hydraulic unit supplies pressure to the clutch slave cylinder and gearbox selector actuator. A selector-angle cylinder moves the shaft across the gate and a shift-travel cylinder engages the chosen gear; position sensors report their movements. The clutch slave has a travel sensor. The MSS54 engine controller and SMG control unit exchange information over a dedicated CAN connection to coordinate the shift and engine torque.

BMW's documented shift sequence controls clutch release and engine torque, engages the selected synchronised gear, then controls clutch re-engagement and restores torque. Driver-facing sequential selection alone does not establish a racing dog-box or sequential drum. The selected Drivelogic programme changes shift behaviour; compare like-for-like conditions when investigating a complaint. BMW SMG II training, printed pp. 3–5, 16–18 and 27–28.

Hydraulic supply and normal pump operation

The documented hydraulic unit includes an electric pump and relay, pressure accumulator, non-return valve, pressure and temperature sensors and solenoid valves. BMW's training example describes the pump switching on below 45 bar and off at 80 bar. These are SMG II training values for this system, not generic limits for other models or a substitute for the current vehicle-specific test plan. The unit may prime when the car is unlocked or the driver's door is opened if pressure is low; a brief pump sound at that point is not proof of a fault. If pressure cannot be built, BMW describes shift restrictions and a warning. BMW SMG II training, printed pp. 10–11 and 23–24.

The pressure accumulator can retain dangerous pressure with the ignition off. Use BMW's current workshop procedure and prescribed equipment before disturbing the hydraulic system; do not loosen a line to check pressure. The actuator hydraulic circuit and gearbox lubrication have distinct functions: identify the specified fluids and correct filling and checking procedure for the exact vehicle rather than mixing them.

Documented E46 M3 SMG relay service action

BMW service action SI B23 01 04, November 2004 describes premature hydraulic-unit relay failure on certain E46 M3 S54 SMG cars produced through 31 March 2004. A failed relay can prevent the system building the pressure needed to shift and illuminate the fault lamp. The action specifies both a relay-connector pin-assignment change and relay replacement; replacing a relay alone is not evidence that the action was completed. BMW says to determine applicability through its service system, not chassis-number ranges alone. Check VIN and service history and follow the current procedure. Low pressure still requires a proper electrical and hydraulic diagnosis, and this action does not establish prevalence across all SMG systems.

Fault patterns and what to check

ObservationUseful investigationLimits
Pump runs repeatedly, runs for a long time or a hydraulic pressure fault is storedRecord pressure sensor values and pump command over the manufacturer-specified test; check power supply, relay, wiring and documented hydraulic leakage and pressure retention.A cycling pump is normal when pressure needs rebuilding. Cycling alone cannot distinguish a pump, accumulator, non-return valve, leak, pressure sensor or wiring fault.
Pressure reading or pump behaviour implausibleCheck the pressure signal, reference and supply circuits with the applicable test plan and compare commanded pump operation with pressure feedback.BMW describes a fallback strategy for an open or shorted pressure sensor that runs the unit on a timed basis. An operating pump does not establish a healthy sensor or true system pressure.
No crank or no gear engagement at restRead SMG, engine and immobiliser faults; verify the requested lever position, brake input, selected gear and clutch/pressure states. Check bonnet contact status and its plausibility where relevant.BMW's documented start sequence requires neutral lever position and brake application; the starting sequence also checks other conditions. Bonnet status affects clutch engagement in the example. Do not bypass interlocks.
Gear selection fault or unexpected neutralRecord requested versus recognised gear, selector-angle and shift-travel feedback, clutch movement, system pressure and related electrical faults under the conditions specified by BMW.Position sensor, actuator, wiring, hydraulic pressure, clutch release and gearbox mechanical faults can produce overlapping symptoms. Do not condemn the gearbox solely from the displayed gear.
Jerky take-up, slip or failed adaptationRecord engine speed, transmission input speed, gear, clutch position and relevant faults; assess mechanical clutch, hydraulic and electrical causes before performing the specified learning procedure.BMW's training text associates its fault-code 68 example with a speed discrepancy and clutch slip; check the actual tool's fault definition and conditions for the vehicle. A reset cannot repair a worn or contaminated clutch.
Hot-only complaint or inconsistent shiftingRecord hydraulic and gearbox temperatures, voltage, pressure trend and faults when cold and when the complaint occurs. Check engine and transmission communications and relevant sensor plausibility.Heat correlation narrows the conditions for testing; it does not by itself prove a particular pump, temperature sensor or control unit has failed.

The sensor fallback, starting interlock, bonnet inputs, actuator layout and failure responses above come from the E46 M3 SMG II training material, printed pp. 11, 16–18, 23–26 and its fault tables. A training manual explains the system; use the current BMW test plan for measurement conditions and acceptance. BMW SMG II training and fault tables.

A practical diagnostic sequence

  1. Record the customer complaint and when it occurs: cold/hot, starting, first/reverse selection, take-up or a particular shift. Record dashboard indications, mode, selected programme, previous repairs and battery condition.
  2. Read all relevant control units before clearing codes: SMG, DME, stability control and starting/immobiliser where applicable. Save fault status and environmental data; a communication or low-voltage event may generate faults in multiple units.
  3. Check battery supply before interpreting borderline entries. BMW's SMG II diagnosis chapter states that self-diagnosis requires ignition on and at least 10 V and that voltage below approximately 10 V can record erroneous entries; this is a diagnostic precondition in that document, not a pass/fail battery health specification. Source: supplied BMW ST043 SMG II, PDF p. 36.
  4. Using supported BMW diagnostics, check displayed request, brake and bonnet signals, recognised gear and clutch/selector positions. Compare pressure and pump command where appropriate; assess hydraulic, electrical and mechanical evidence together.
  5. Test the affected circuit or subsystem using the prescribed procedure and prerequisites. Inspect the clutch and release mechanism if evidence points there; examine the selector and gearbox only after establishing whether command, pressure and feedback are consistent.
  6. After the necessary repair, perform the applicable bleeding, initialisation or adaptation functions and their specified prerequisites. BMW lists different service functions after different repairs; do not assume one reset suits every job. Verify the original complaint with the correct vehicle-specific road-test procedure.

See the broader F1-style gearbox comparison, automated manual control and diagnosis and clutch guide.

For a later and mechanically different BMW system, see E9x M3 M DCT operation and diagnosis.