Tuning Wiki

This is a historical revision. Read the current page or return to its history.

Page organisation in this revision
Page type
Technical article
Subject
Emissions control
Parent
Section level
Applies to
No ECU-specific applicability
Tool groups
None
Manufacturers
None

Changes from revision 1 to revision 1

Removed text is struck through; added text is highlighted.

Two solids in the same channels

Everything the filter keeps is either soot or ash. Soot is the carbon from diesel that did not finish burning in the cylinder, together with some heavy hydrocarbons stuck to it. It is black, it is combustible, and a regeneration exists to oxidise it. Ash is whatever is caught in the same place and will not oxidise at any temperature the filter can survive. A regeneration that has worked leaves the ash behind and the pressure drop only partly restored. Treating the two as one blockage is why a forced regeneration is sometimes run on a filter that can only get hotter and dirtier.

Soot

The engine makes soot whenever the spray is locally rich, which a diesel spray always is somewhere in the plume. More EGR, a leaking injector, a boost leak, low rail pressure and a cold combustion all raise the rate. The wall collects it first inside the pores and then as a layer on the inlet-channel surface. That layer is useful up to a point: a depth filtration in the pores is followed by a cake on the surface, and the cake itself filters. Past that point the layer thickens, the pressure drop rises with the square of the flow, and the control unit has to burn the cake back before the heat of a later burn, or the back-pressure on the engine, becomes the failure.

How hot the cake has to be depends on the coating and the additive:

Oxygen on an uncoated wall becomes effective around 550 to 600 °C. Nitrogen dioxide, made by platinum on the filter or on the catalyst upstream, oxidises soot from about 250 °C while the exhaust is lean. A cerium fuel-borne catalyst dispersed through the soot brings the oxygen burn down, commonly described around 450 °C.

A regeneration that reaches temperature and has air will remove most of the combustible cake. A little residual soot is normal. The model’s empty is a calibrated residual, not a laboratory-clean wall.

Ash

Ash arrives from three places. Lubricant additives are the main one on a catalysed filter with no fuel-borne additive: zinc, phosphorus, calcium and magnesium from the oil, as sulphates and phosphates, plus a little iron and other wear metal. Fuel-borne catalyst is the second: cerium oxide from Eolys DPX42, iron oxide from Eolys Powerflex. The third is anything else incombustible that the exhaust carries, including residue from sulphur in the fuel on engines that still see it. Low-SAPS oil exists because the first of those sources is under the manufacturer’s control. The handbook grade is the one the ash capacity was calculated with. A high-SAPS oil fills the same brick sooner.

Ash does not form a uniform layer. Flow drives it to the closed end of each inlet channel, where it packs as a plug. The plug shortens the channel, so the filter loses volume from the back of the brick forwards. It also raises the pressure of a filter that the soot model says is empty. That residual, read at a known exhaust flow after a regeneration the soot model believes has finished, is the practical measurement of ash.

Oil consumption and additive dose decide the rate. An engine burning oil, a turbo seal feeding oil into the exhaust, or a fuel-borne catalyst that has been over-dosed, fills a filter that the mileage would still call young. A cerium system was serviced on a shorter distance for this reason. An iron system doses less metal and leaves less ash per kilometre. Neither system burns the ash off later.

How the two show up on a pressure reading

Differential pressure rises with both. The shapes differ once the reading is taken against exhaust flow, which is the comparison the load model makes.

A soot cake raises the pressure across the whole flow range, and a successful burn brings the curve back down to the ash line. Ash lifts the baseline. After the burn, the pressure at a given flow is still higher than a new filter. More flow makes that gap more obvious, which is why a loaded-looking reading at idle can be a small soot mass, and a modest reading at full load can still be a filter that is short of volume.

A workshop regeneration commanded against ash spends the fuel, puts heat into a brick that has less free volume than the calibration assumes, and finishes at the same residual pressure it started from once the soot fraction has gone. The next step is cleaning or replacement, then a reset of the stored ash mass so the control unit agrees with the brick that was just fitted.

Rendered revisions

Open each version to inspect formatting, tables and photographs.

Revision 1: Soot and ash in a diesel particulate filter

Two solids in the same channels

Everything the filter keeps is either soot or ash. Soot is the carbon from diesel that did not finish burning in the cylinder, together with some heavy hydrocarbons stuck to it. It is black, it is combustible, and a regeneration exists to oxidise it. Ash is whatever is caught in the same place and will not oxidise at any temperature the filter can survive. A regeneration that has worked leaves the ash behind and the pressure drop only partly restored. Treating the two as one blockage is why a forced regeneration is sometimes run on a filter that can only get hotter and dirtier.

Soot

The engine makes soot whenever the spray is locally rich, which a diesel spray always is somewhere in the plume. More EGR, a leaking injector, a boost leak, low rail pressure and a cold combustion all raise the rate. The wall collects it first inside the pores and then as a layer on the inlet-channel surface. That layer is useful up to a point: a depth filtration in the pores is followed by a cake on the surface, and the cake itself filters. Past that point the layer thickens, the pressure drop rises with the square of the flow, and the control unit has to burn the cake back before the heat of a later burn, or the back-pressure on the engine, becomes the failure.

How hot the cake has to be depends on the coating and the additive:

  • Oxygen on an uncoated wall becomes effective around 550 to 600 °C.
  • Nitrogen dioxide, made by platinum on the filter or on the catalyst upstream, oxidises soot from about 250 °C while the exhaust is lean.
  • A cerium fuel-borne catalyst dispersed through the soot brings the oxygen burn down, commonly described around 450 °C.

A regeneration that reaches temperature and has air will remove most of the combustible cake. A little residual soot is normal. The model’s empty is a calibrated residual, not a laboratory-clean wall.

Ash

Ash arrives from three places. Lubricant additives are the main one on a catalysed filter with no fuel-borne additive: zinc, phosphorus, calcium and magnesium from the oil, as sulphates and phosphates, plus a little iron and other wear metal. Fuel-borne catalyst is the second: cerium oxide from Eolys DPX42, iron oxide from Eolys Powerflex. The third is anything else incombustible that the exhaust carries, including residue from sulphur in the fuel on engines that still see it. Low-SAPS oil exists because the first of those sources is under the manufacturer’s control. The handbook grade is the one the ash capacity was calculated with. A high-SAPS oil fills the same brick sooner.

Ash does not form a uniform layer. Flow drives it to the closed end of each inlet channel, where it packs as a plug. The plug shortens the channel, so the filter loses volume from the back of the brick forwards. It also raises the pressure of a filter that the soot model says is empty. That residual, read at a known exhaust flow after a regeneration the soot model believes has finished, is the practical measurement of ash.

Oil consumption and additive dose decide the rate. An engine burning oil, a turbo seal feeding oil into the exhaust, or a fuel-borne catalyst that has been over-dosed, fills a filter that the mileage would still call young. A cerium system was serviced on a shorter distance for this reason. An iron system doses less metal and leaves less ash per kilometre. Neither system burns the ash off later.

How the two show up on a pressure reading

Differential pressure rises with both. The shapes differ once the reading is taken against exhaust flow, which is the comparison the load model makes.

  • A soot cake raises the pressure across the whole flow range, and a successful burn brings the curve back down to the ash line.
  • Ash lifts the baseline. After the burn, the pressure at a given flow is still higher than a new filter. More flow makes that gap more obvious, which is why a loaded-looking reading at idle can be a small soot mass, and a modest reading at full load can still be a filter that is short of volume.

A workshop regeneration commanded against ash spends the fuel, puts heat into a brick that has less free volume than the calibration assumes, and finishes at the same residual pressure it started from once the soot fraction has gone. The next step is cleaning or replacement, then a reset of the stored ash mass so the control unit agrees with the brick that was just fitted.

Revision 1: Soot and ash in a diesel particulate filter

Two solids in the same channels

Everything the filter keeps is either soot or ash. Soot is the carbon from diesel that did not finish burning in the cylinder, together with some heavy hydrocarbons stuck to it. It is black, it is combustible, and a regeneration exists to oxidise it. Ash is whatever is caught in the same place and will not oxidise at any temperature the filter can survive. A regeneration that has worked leaves the ash behind and the pressure drop only partly restored. Treating the two as one blockage is why a forced regeneration is sometimes run on a filter that can only get hotter and dirtier.

Soot

The engine makes soot whenever the spray is locally rich, which a diesel spray always is somewhere in the plume. More EGR, a leaking injector, a boost leak, low rail pressure and a cold combustion all raise the rate. The wall collects it first inside the pores and then as a layer on the inlet-channel surface. That layer is useful up to a point: a depth filtration in the pores is followed by a cake on the surface, and the cake itself filters. Past that point the layer thickens, the pressure drop rises with the square of the flow, and the control unit has to burn the cake back before the heat of a later burn, or the back-pressure on the engine, becomes the failure.

How hot the cake has to be depends on the coating and the additive:

  • Oxygen on an uncoated wall becomes effective around 550 to 600 °C.
  • Nitrogen dioxide, made by platinum on the filter or on the catalyst upstream, oxidises soot from about 250 °C while the exhaust is lean.
  • A cerium fuel-borne catalyst dispersed through the soot brings the oxygen burn down, commonly described around 450 °C.

A regeneration that reaches temperature and has air will remove most of the combustible cake. A little residual soot is normal. The model’s empty is a calibrated residual, not a laboratory-clean wall.

Ash

Ash arrives from three places. Lubricant additives are the main one on a catalysed filter with no fuel-borne additive: zinc, phosphorus, calcium and magnesium from the oil, as sulphates and phosphates, plus a little iron and other wear metal. Fuel-borne catalyst is the second: cerium oxide from Eolys DPX42, iron oxide from Eolys Powerflex. The third is anything else incombustible that the exhaust carries, including residue from sulphur in the fuel on engines that still see it. Low-SAPS oil exists because the first of those sources is under the manufacturer’s control. The handbook grade is the one the ash capacity was calculated with. A high-SAPS oil fills the same brick sooner.

Ash does not form a uniform layer. Flow drives it to the closed end of each inlet channel, where it packs as a plug. The plug shortens the channel, so the filter loses volume from the back of the brick forwards. It also raises the pressure of a filter that the soot model says is empty. That residual, read at a known exhaust flow after a regeneration the soot model believes has finished, is the practical measurement of ash.

Oil consumption and additive dose decide the rate. An engine burning oil, a turbo seal feeding oil into the exhaust, or a fuel-borne catalyst that has been over-dosed, fills a filter that the mileage would still call young. A cerium system was serviced on a shorter distance for this reason. An iron system doses less metal and leaves less ash per kilometre. Neither system burns the ash off later.

How the two show up on a pressure reading

Differential pressure rises with both. The shapes differ once the reading is taken against exhaust flow, which is the comparison the load model makes.

  • A soot cake raises the pressure across the whole flow range, and a successful burn brings the curve back down to the ash line.
  • Ash lifts the baseline. After the burn, the pressure at a given flow is still higher than a new filter. More flow makes that gap more obvious, which is why a loaded-looking reading at idle can be a small soot mass, and a modest reading at full load can still be a filter that is short of volume.

A workshop regeneration commanded against ash spends the fuel, puts heat into a brick that has less free volume than the calibration assumes, and finishes at the same residual pressure it started from once the soot fraction has gone. The next step is cleaning or replacement, then a reset of the stored ash mass so the control unit agrees with the brick that was just fitted.