Tuning Wiki

This is a historical revision. Read the current page or return to its history.

Page organisation in this revision
Page type
Technical article
Subject
Emissions control
Parent
Section level
Applies to
No ECU-specific applicability
Tool groups
None
Manufacturers
Audi, Porsche, SEAT, Škoda, Volkswagen

The Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal, often called Dieselgate, concerned diesel vehicles marketed under Volkswagen Group brands whose emissions controls operated differently in laboratory tests and normal driving. Independent research triggered regulatory investigation; in 2017 Volkswagen AG pleaded guilty in the United States to offences arising from a scheme to evade US emissions tests. The affected vehicles, technical fixes and legal outcomes vary by engine, market and model year. US Department of Justice: VW sentence.

See also emissions cheating and diesel enforcement and petrol and diesel emissions.

What was the problem?

Diesel engines can produce high nitrogen oxide (NOx) emissions, which aftertreatment and exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) help control. In the US case, regulators said VW software recognised the conditions of an emissions test and changed how the emissions controls worked, allowing certification results that did not reflect normal road operation. NOx includes nitric oxide and nitrogen dioxide; it contributes to ground-level ozone and particulate pollution. The case concerns air pollutants and certification, not simply a car using more fuel than advertised. EPA: Volkswagen violations; EPA: ozone basics.

A normal emissions test follows a defined drive cycle on a dynamometer. Software can use measured operating conditions to distinguish tests from other driving; the specific logic and control strategy differ among engine generations. This article does not suggest that a particular diagnostic value, driving condition or calibration number alone proves an unlawful device. Regulators considered software, operating behaviour, certification and other evidence together. EPA Inspector General: detection and compliance review.

How the issue came to light

  1. 2013–2014: the International Council on Clean Transportation (ICCT) commissioned West Virginia University’s Center for Alternative Fuels, Engines and Emissions to test three diesel vehicles, including a VW Jetta and Passat, using portable emissions measurement equipment (PEMS) on California routes. ICCT reported that the two VWs passed the laboratory certification cycle at CARB’s facility but produced much higher NOx in road testing. For the vehicles and routes tested, ICCT reported 15–35 times the applicable US laboratory standard for the Jetta and 5–20 times for the Passat. These are results for particular vehicles and routes, not a measurement of every affected vehicle or a direct legal pass/fail determination using a different road cycle. ICCT: study and test results.
  2. 2014–2015: California Air Resources Board (CARB) and the US Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) investigated the discrepancies and sought explanations and remedies. A laboratory/road difference alone did not prove manipulation; the subsequent investigation established more about the software. EPA Inspector General: investigation review.
  3. December 2014–2015, early recall: according to the US government’s civil complaint, VW issued a recall for 2.0-litre vehicles after offering software optimisation as a response to high NOx readings. Subsequent CARB testing, coordinated with EPA, found only limited reductions. The complaint records allegations in that civil action; the 2017 corporate guilty plea was a separate criminal proceeding. DOJ: 2016 civil complaint, paragraphs 88–89.
  4. 18 September 2015: EPA issued a notice of violation concerning certain 2.0-litre diesels. VW admitted that affected vehicles contained the software; additional US allegations concerning 3.0-litre vehicles followed in November. EPA: timeline and affected vehicles.
  5. 2016–2017: US courts approved separate settlement measures for the 2.0-litre and 3.0-litre vehicles and a third civil resolution. In April 2017 a federal court sentenced Volkswagen AG following its guilty plea. EPA: civil settlement; DOJ: criminal sentence.

Vehicles, engines and markets

In the United States, EPA’s civil case covered approximately 590,000 model-year 2009–2016 diesel vehicles, comprising 2.0-litre and 3.0-litre groups, under Volkswagen, Audi and Porsche brands. Coverage of an individual model is limited to the listed model years and configurations; other vehicles with similar badges are not automatically included. EPA: affected vehicles and timeline; DOJ: vehicle groups.

  • US 2.0-litre: covered vehicles included certain Jetta, Jetta SportWagen, Golf, Golf SportWagen, Beetle, Passat and Audi A3 diesels. US model years and specific models differ; consult the official list.
  • US 3.0-litre: included certain VW Touareg, Audi Q7 and other Audi models, plus Porsche Cayenne diesels. The 3.0-litre settlement and approved modifications are separate from the 2.0-litre settlement.
  • Europe and the UK: affected EA189 diesels were sold in Volkswagen, Audi, SEAT and Škoda vehicles. In October 2015 the UK government said VW had admitted nearly 1.2 million UK vehicles were affected, all diesel vehicles tested and approved to Euro 5. This is a national estimate, not a list of all diesels sold in the UK. UK Department for Transport statement.

Do not treat EA189, EA288, “2.0 TDI” and every VW diesel as interchangeable. VW’s 2018 German administrative notice identified EA189 engines worldwide and EA288 Generation 3 engines in the US and Canada in the specific conduct it addressed. That notice does not establish that every EA288 or every European EA288 was affected. The 3.0-litre case also concerns a different engine group. Verify the VIN, engine code, market and relevant campaign. VW: 2018 German administrative order.

Remedies and recalls

Remedies depended on the jurisdiction, the vehicle and the settlement. US remedies included buybacks or lease termination for eligible owners, approved emissions modifications for some vehicles, and environmental mitigation and zero-emission vehicle investment. They were not a single universal software flash. EPA: settlement details and owner remedies.

For example, EPA and CARB approved a two-phase remedy for specified US model-year 2015 2.0-litre Generation 3 vehicles: first a software change, then additional software and replacement hardware including a diesel particulate filter, diesel oxidation catalyst and NOx catalyst. This example must not be assumed to apply to other engine generations, European cars or every recall. EPA: Generation 3 remedy.

European legal issues continued after recalls. In 2022 the EU Court of Justice considered a VW update that reduced EGR outside a specified temperature window, and held that a device ensuring compliance only within such a window generally constitutes a prohibited defeat device under the applicable EU regulation, subject to the legal exceptions. The ruling concerns the circumstances and questions referred in those cases; it is not a finding that every temperature-based control is unlawful. Court of Justice of the EU: July 2022 judgments.

Financial and legal consequences

  • United States, criminal: Volkswagen AG pleaded guilty to conspiracy, obstruction of justice and importation by false statements. The court sentenced it in 2017 to a $2.8 billion criminal fine. This was a criminal conviction of the company, separate from the civil settlements and owner remedies. DOJ: 2017 sentence.
  • United States, civil: VW and related entities agreed to $1.45 billion in civil penalties in a coordinated resolution involving environmental and customs claims, separate from buybacks, modifications and mitigation. These categories should not be conflated. EPA: civil settlement; DOJ: customs settlement.
  • Germany, VW AG: in 2018 the Braunschweig prosecutor issued a €1 billion administrative fine order for supervisory failures, comprising €5 million sanction and €995 million disgorgement of economic benefits. VW accepted it and did not appeal. It is a different proceeding from the US criminal case. VW: administrative order.
  • Germany, Audi AG: in 2018 Munich prosecutors issued an €800 million administrative fine order concerning regulatory deviations in certain V6 and V8 diesel engines and vehicles. It comprised €5 million sanction and €795 million disgorgement; Audi accepted the order. VW: Audi order.
  • England and Wales, preliminary court finding: in 2020 the High Court decided preliminary issues in the EA189 group litigation and found that the software function before it was a defeat device under the EU regulation. This preliminary decision did not itself decide every claimant’s damages. High Court: preliminary issues judgment.
  • England and Wales, private litigation: VW reported that roughly 91,000 group claims were settled out of court in May 2022 for £193 million, plus a separate amount for legal fees and other costs. This was a private civil settlement, not a UK regulator’s fine or a criminal conviction. VW: 2022 annual report litigation note.

For other manufacturers and related enforcement cases, see emissions cheating and enforcement. Amounts in separate proceedings may cover different conduct, entities and remedies; headline settlement costs are not all fines.

Individuals and accountability

In the United States, VW engineer James Robert Liang pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 40 months in prison and a $200,000 fine. VW manager Oliver Schmidt pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 84 months in prison and a $400,000 fine. These sentences concern individual criminal cases, not the corporate fine. DOJ: Volkswagen case and related defendants.

In Germany, the Munich II court in 2023 convicted three people in the Audi proceedings of fraud, giving suspended prison sentences and ordering payments as probation conditions. Court reporting stated the defendants appealed and the judgment was not final as of its November 2025 update; that status should be checked before describing the outcome as final. Bavarian courts: 2023 judgment; Bavarian courts: 2025 status.

VW also reported that, in a separate EA189 fraud trial in Braunschweig, four defendants were convicted in May 2025; two of their prison sentences were suspended. According to VW’s 2025 annual report all four appealed and the judgment was not final at the time of that report. This is a separate case from the Audi judgment above and from proceedings concerning VW’s former chief executive. VW 2025 annual report: litigation.

What it changed

The scandal exposed the limits of relying only on a predictable laboratory cycle. EU rules introduced real-driving emissions testing alongside laboratory procedures; independent in-use testing and scrutiny of software also became more prominent. Actual road results vary with temperature, journey and load; a road/laboratory discrepancy is a reason to investigate, not proof by itself of a defeat device. European Commission Joint Research Centre: vehicle emissions manipulation and testing.

Workshop and owner checks

  1. Record the VIN, engine code, market, production date and ECU identification. Check the manufacturer’s official VIN recall or campaign system and any relevant national authority information.
  2. Check the recorded campaign completion and software version against the manufacturer’s service information for that exact vehicle. A calibration number by itself is not a legal finding or a substitute for a campaign lookup.
  3. Investigate present faults normally: read codes and freeze-frame data, check sensor plausibility, exhaust leaks, EGR, DPF and the vehicle’s NOx aftertreatment. Existing faults do not prove that a defeat device is present.
  4. If there is a concern about emissions after an update, record symptoms and use the approved diagnostic procedure. Normal MOT smoke testing does not measure NOx or establish whether test-recognition software is present.
  5. For owners seeking a remedy or compensation, establish which jurisdiction, vehicle group, claim deadline and settlement terms apply; past settlements may no longer be open.

Use the emissions overview for links to system descriptions, sensors and testing equipment. Refer to primary case records and manufacturer campaign information for the latest status of a specific vehicle or legal case.