Removed text is struck through; added text is highlighted.
Emissions cheating describes conduct intended to make a vehicle or engine appear compliant while its real-world pollution controls are compromised, or to obtain certification using false information. Cases range from manufacturer software and misleading test data to aftermarket parts sold to disable emissions controls. This page documents selected cases from the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe; it is not a complete list.
See also Petrol and diesel emissions for the systems involved and their normal operation.
Defeat devices and misleading test results
In US vehicle regulation, a defeat device generally includes an element of design that senses operating conditions and reduces an emission control system's effectiveness under conditions reasonably expected in normal operation and use, subject to specific regulatory exceptions. Auxiliary emission control strategies can have legitimate purposes; whether a particular strategy is lawful depends on the applicable regulation, disclosure, certification and facts. An emission-control fault or a difference between laboratory and road measurements is not, by itself, proof of cheating. Rules outside the United States differ. EPA: Cummins frequently asked questions.
In some enforcement cases, regulators alleged that a vehicle behaved differently during certification tests and ordinary driving. Investigators can compare approved test results with independent laboratory testing and on-road portable emissions measurement systems, review diagnostic and certification records, inspect software and components, and investigate sales records. A suspicious measurement calls for further investigation; a legal finding depends on the evidence in the particular case. Volkswagen's case is an example of test recognition alleged by EPA. EPA: Volkswagen violations.
Controls exist to reduce pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), which contribute to ground-level ozone and particulate pollution. Removing or defeating them can increase pollution even when a vehicle appears to run normally. EPA: ground-level ozone basics.
Reading the enforcement figures
The cases below are selected examples, in US dollars at the amounts announced. A civil settlement generally resolves allegations; it is not itself a criminal conviction or necessarily an admission of liability. A criminal fine follows a criminal case. Civil penalties, criminal fines, forfeiture, recalls, consumer compensation and environmental mitigation are different obligations and should not automatically be added together. A proposed settlement or administrative order is described as such, and an announced amount is not proof of collection.
US heavy-duty diesel manufacturers
1998 heavy-duty diesel settlements
EPA and the US Department of Justice announced settlements with seven diesel engine manufacturers after alleging that engine controls reduced NOx emissions during laboratory certification testing but substantially increased emissions during highway driving. EPA described approximately 1.3 million heavy-duty diesel engines overall. The announced aggregate civil penalty was $83.4 million; the more than $1 billion headline also included other programmes and obligations. EPA: 1998 settlement announcement and penalty breakdown; DOJ: 1998 announcement.
Caterpillar Inc.: $25 million civil penalty.
Cummins Engine Company: $25 million civil penalty.
Detroit Diesel Corporation: $12.5 million civil penalty.
Navistar International Transportation Corporation: $2.9 million civil penalty.
Mack Trucks and Renault Véhicules Industriels: $13 million jointly; this is one shared amount, not $13 million per company. Renault was a French company.
Volvo Truck Corporation: $5 million civil penalty. Volvo was a Swedish company.
Company names reflect the EPA announcement at the time; the list includes foreign companies because they were parties to the US settlement. The listed amounts together total $83.4 million and should not be counted again as seven separate $83.4 million penalties.
Cummins: Ram diesel pickups, 2024
In the 2024 US and California settlement, EPA alleged that Cummins installed defeat devices in approximately 630,000 model-year 2013–2019 Ram 2500 and 3500 diesel pickups and installed undisclosed auxiliary emission control devices in approximately 330,000 model-year 2019–2023 pickups. The two groups and allegations are distinct; the latter figure should not be described as a finding that all of those vehicles had illegal defeat devices.
The settlement included a $1.642 billion federal Clean Air Act civil penalty; including California penalties, the announced civil penalties totalled $1.675 billion. Recall and environmental mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Cummins settlement; EPA: case questions and answers.
US diesel aftermarket businesses
These cases concern aftermarket products or sales, rather than original equipment manufacturers' certification. The civil cases below describe allegations and settlements; they do not by themselves establish criminal guilt.
H&S Performance: EPA announced a proposed 2015 settlement with a $1 million civil penalty, plus a separate $400,000 environmental mitigation project, concerning alleged sales of products that bypassed diesel emissions controls. EPA: H&S Performance.
Performance Diesel Inc.: a 2019 EPA/DOJ settlement included a $1.1 million civil penalty and restrictions concerning diesel defeat products. EPA: Performance Diesel.
Xtreme Diesel Performance LLC (XDP): a 2021 settlement included a $1.125 million civil penalty to resolve allegations involving aftermarket defeat devices. EPA: XDP settlement.
Thoroughbred Performance Products, doing business as Thoroughbred Diesel: EPA announced a $1.25 million civil settlement in 2024 over alleged sales of defeat devices. EPA: Thoroughbred Diesel.
Sinister Manufacturing Company, doing business as Sinister Diesel: in 2023 the company agreed to plead guilty and to a $500,000 criminal fine and a separate $500,000 civil penalty. Those are distinct components of the announced resolution. DOJ: Sinister Diesel.
Rudy's Performance Parts Inc.: following its guilty plea, the company was sentenced in 2024 to a $2.4 million criminal fine. Its owner received a separate $600,000 criminal fine. DOJ: Rudy's Performance Parts.
Individuals convicted
Enforcement can also reach individuals. In the Volkswagen case, engineer James Robert Liang pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 40 months in prison and a $200,000 fine. Volkswagen manager Oliver Schmidt pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 84 months in prison and a $400,000 fine. DOJ: United States v. Volkswagen and related defendants.
In the FCA case, engineer Emanuele Palma pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate the Clean Air Act and was sentenced in 2023 to one day of time served. DOJ: United States v. Emanuele Palma.
Other diesel cases in the US market
These cases involved foreign parent companies or multinational groups and US operations. They are included for context and are not labelled as US-headquartered diesel manufacturers.
Volkswagen AG and affiliates: a 2017 US civil decree imposed $1.45 billion in civil penalties involving environmental and customs claims. This is separate from Volkswagen AG's $2.8 billion criminal fine following its guilty plea, as well as buybacks and other remedies. EPA's diesel cases covered approximately 590,000 US vehicles. EPA: VW civil settlement; EPA: VW violations; EPA: criminal case background.
FCA US LLC and FCA Italy: see the detailed Fiat Chrysler diesel emissions scandal page. A 2019 US and California civil settlement over alleged undisclosed software and excess emissions included a $305 million civil penalty. In a separate criminal case, FCA US LLC was sentenced in 2022 to a $96,145,784 criminal fine and $203,572,892 forfeiture; the approximately $300 million criminal financial sanction was not all a fine. The cases involved model-year 2014–2016 diesel Jeep Grand Cherokee and Ram 1500 vehicles. EPA: 2019 civil settlements; EPA: 2022 criminal sentence.
Daimler AG and Mercedes-Benz USA LLC: see also the detailed Mercedes-Benz diesel emissions scandal page. The US civil settlement entered in 2021 involved approximately 250,000 diesel cars and vans and an $875 million civil penalty, including the federal and California portions. Other recall and mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Daimler and Mercedes-Benz settlement.
Hino Motors Ltd. and US subsidiaries: the 2025 civil resolution concerning false and fabricated emissions-testing data included a $525 million total civil penalty. In a separate criminal case Hino was sentenced to a $521.76 million criminal fine and a $1.087 billion forfeiture judgment. The resolution provides credits for certain other payments, so the figures must not simply be added. EPA: Hino civil settlement summary; EPA: Hino criminal sentence.Volkswagen AG and affiliates: a 2017 US civil decree imposed $1.45 billion in civil penalties involving environmental and customs claims. This is separate from Volkswagen AG's $2.8 billion criminal fine following its guilty plea, as well as buybacks and other remedies. EPA's diesel cases covered approximately 590,000 US vehicles. EPA: VW civil settlement; EPA: VW violations; EPA: criminal case background.
FCA US LLC and FCA Italy: a 2019 US and California civil settlement over alleged undisclosed software and excess emissions included a $305 million civil penalty. In a separate criminal case, FCA US LLC was sentenced in 2022 to a $96,145,784 criminal fine and $203,572,892 forfeiture; the approximately $300 million criminal financial sanction was not all a fine. The cases involved model-year 2014–2016 diesel Jeep Grand Cherokee and Ram 1500 vehicles. EPA: 2019 civil settlements; EPA: 2022 criminal sentence.
Daimler AG and Mercedes-Benz USA LLC: the US civil settlement entered in 2021 involved approximately 250,000 diesel cars and vans and an $875 million civil penalty, including the federal and California portions. Other recall and mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Daimler and Mercedes-Benz settlement.
Hino Motors Ltd. and US subsidiaries: the 2025 civil resolution concerning false and fabricated emissions-testing data included a $525 million total civil penalty. In a separate criminal case Hino was sentenced to a $521.76 million criminal fine and a $1.087 billion forfeiture judgment. The resolution provides credits for certain other payments, so the figures must not simply be added. EPA: Hino civil settlement summary; EPA: Hino criminal sentence.These examples illustrate different conduct and legal outcomes. Consult the linked case records for the exact defendants, products, dates, allegations, settlement terms and any later developments.
For a broader list of resolved US cases, see the EPA vehicle and engine enforcement case resolutions. The conduct, legal status and penalties differ by case.
For the discovery, affected vehicles, recalls and legal outcomes in the Volkswagen case, see Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal (Dieselgate).United Kingdom: court findings and owner compensation
Volkswagen Group vehicles with EA189 engines: In April 2020 the High Court of England and Wales found, as a preliminary issue in the VW NOx group litigation, that the software function fitted to the engines was a defeat device. The claim covered owners of Volkswagen, Audi, Škoda and SEAT vehicles. In May 2022 approximately 91,000 claims were settled out of court for £193 million, plus a separate contribution to legal fees and other costs. The settlement was compensation in civil litigation, not a UK regulatory fine; it was made without an admission of liability. The preliminary finding should not be confused with a final judgment on each owner's claim. High Court judgment; Volkswagen annual report: litigation; claimants' solicitors: settlement.
Pan-NOx litigation: In July 2026, the High Court considered strategies in sample diesel vehicles from a number of manufacturers. The court rejected most of the principal allegations but made adverse findings about specific strategies in certain Mercedes-Benz vehicles and Peugeot-Citroën Euro 5 vehicles. This judgment did not decide individual compensation or impose a manufacturer fine. It does not establish that every vehicle or manufacturer named in the litigation had an unlawful device; the proceedings and any appeals need to be checked for subsequent developments. Judiciary of England and Wales: judgment summary, 10 July 2026.
The UK Department for Transport also investigated diesel emissions after the VW disclosure. In the 37 vehicle types tested in the UK, the tests found no evidence of test-cycle manipulation of the kind used by the VW Group by other manufacturers, while reporting differences between laboratory and real-world NOx emissions. That result should not be treated as a finding that every other emissions-control strategy was lawful. Department for Transport: testing programme.The UK Department for Transport also investigated diesel emissions after the VW disclosure. It found no evidence of the particular VW test-cycle detection used in the other 37 vehicles tested, while reporting differences between laboratory and real-world NOx emissions. That result should not be treated as a finding that every other emissions-control strategy was lawful. Department for Transport: testing programme.Europe: German diesel-related administrative fines
The German cases below involve administrative offence notices concerning supervisory failures and regulatory deviations. The monetary totals commonly reported include both the sanction and the recovery of economic benefits; they are not all criminal fines or findings that every employee intentionally cheated.
Volkswagen AG, 2018 — €1 billion: The Braunschweig public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent breach of supervisory duties in connection with diesel engines. It comprised a €5 million sanction and €995 million in recovered economic benefits. Volkswagen accepted the notice. Its scope included EA189 engines worldwide and EA288 Generation 3 engines in the US and Canada; it must not be read as saying all EA288 engines worldwide were covered. Volkswagen Group: notice; 2018 annual report: scope and payment.
Audi AG, 2018 — €800 million: The Munich II public prosecutor issued an administrative notice for supervision failures concerning regulatory deviations in certain V6/V8 diesel engines and vehicles. The total included €5 million sanction and €795 million recovery of economic benefits. Audi accepted the notice. Volkswagen Group: Audi notice.
Porsche AG, 2019 — €535 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor's notice concerned negligent supervisory breaches in exhaust-gas testing and regulatory deviations in certain vehicles. The total comprised a €4 million penalty and €531 million recovery of economic benefits. Porsche did not appeal. This notice was for negligent supervision, not a finding that all affected Porsche employees deliberately cheated. Porsche: administrative proceedings.
Daimler AG (Mercedes-Benz), 2019 — €870 million: See also the Mercedes-Benz diesel emissions scandal. The Stuttgart public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent supervision in vehicle certification relating to deviations from regulatory requirements in certain vehicles. The total was €4 million sanction and €866 million recovery of economic benefits. Daimler did not challenge the notice, although it maintained objections to separate KBA recall orders. Mercedes-Benz Group: administrative proceedings.Volkswagen AG, 2018 — €1 billion: The Braunschweig public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent breach of supervisory duties in connection with diesel engines. It comprised a €5 million sanction and €995 million in recovered economic benefits. Volkswagen accepted the notice. Its scope included EA189 engines worldwide and EA288 Generation 3 engines in the US and Canada; it must not be read as saying all EA288 engines worldwide were covered. Volkswagen Group: notice; 2018 annual report: scope and payment.
Audi AG, 2018 — €800 million: The Munich II public prosecutor issued an administrative notice for supervision failures concerning regulatory deviations in certain V6/V8 diesel engines and vehicles. The total included €5 million sanction and €795 million recovery of economic benefits. Audi accepted the notice. Volkswagen Group: Audi notice.
Porsche AG, 2019 — €535 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor's notice concerned negligent supervisory breaches in exhaust-gas testing and regulatory deviations in certain vehicles. The total comprised a €4 million penalty and €531 million recovery of economic benefits. Porsche did not appeal. This notice was for negligent supervision, not a finding that all affected Porsche employees deliberately cheated. Porsche: administrative proceedings.
Daimler AG (Mercedes-Benz), 2019 — €870 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent supervision in vehicle certification relating to deviations from regulatory requirements in certain vehicles. The total was €4 million sanction and €866 million recovery of economic benefits. Daimler did not challenge the notice, although it maintained objections to separate KBA recall orders. Mercedes-Benz Group: administrative proceedings.Separate EU competition case: NOx cleaning technology
In 2021 the European Commission fined Volkswagen Group €502,362,000 and BMW €372,827,000 for colluding to restrict competition in technical development of diesel SCR emissions cleaning. Daimler received immunity and no fine after disclosing the cartel; all parties acknowledged participation and settled. This was an antitrust case, distinct from defeat-device investigations: the Commission said it had no indication that the parties coordinated illegal defeat devices and did not determine whether the vehicles complied with emissions standards. The fines must not be presented as penalties for cheating an emissions test. European Commission: decision and fine breakdown.
Open each version to inspect formatting, tables and photographs.
Revision 3: Emissions Cheating, Defeat Devices and Enforcement Cases
Emissions cheating describes conduct intended to make a vehicle or engine appear compliant while its real-world pollution controls are compromised, or to obtain certification using false information. Cases range from manufacturer software and misleading test data to aftermarket parts sold to disable emissions controls. This page documents selected cases from the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe; it is not a complete list.
See also Petrol and diesel emissions for the systems involved and their normal operation.
Defeat devices and misleading test results
In US vehicle regulation, a defeat device generally includes an element of design that senses operating conditions and reduces an emission control system's effectiveness under conditions reasonably expected in normal operation and use, subject to specific regulatory exceptions. Auxiliary emission control strategies can have legitimate purposes; whether a particular strategy is lawful depends on the applicable regulation, disclosure, certification and facts. An emission-control fault or a difference between laboratory and road measurements is not, by itself, proof of cheating. Rules outside the United States differ. EPA: Cummins frequently asked questions.
In some enforcement cases, regulators alleged that a vehicle behaved differently during certification tests and ordinary driving. Investigators can compare approved test results with independent laboratory testing and on-road portable emissions measurement systems, review diagnostic and certification records, inspect software and components, and investigate sales records. A suspicious measurement calls for further investigation; a legal finding depends on the evidence in the particular case. Volkswagen's case is an example of test recognition alleged by EPA. EPA: Volkswagen violations.
Controls exist to reduce pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), which contribute to ground-level ozone and particulate pollution. Removing or defeating them can increase pollution even when a vehicle appears to run normally. EPA: ground-level ozone basics.
Reading the enforcement figures
The cases below are selected examples, in US dollars at the amounts announced. A civil settlement generally resolves allegations; it is not itself a criminal conviction or necessarily an admission of liability. A criminal fine follows a criminal case. Civil penalties, criminal fines, forfeiture, recalls, consumer compensation and environmental mitigation are different obligations and should not automatically be added together. A proposed settlement or administrative order is described as such, and an announced amount is not proof of collection.
US heavy-duty diesel manufacturers
1998 heavy-duty diesel settlements
EPA and the US Department of Justice announced settlements with seven diesel engine manufacturers after alleging that engine controls reduced NOx emissions during laboratory certification testing but substantially increased emissions during highway driving. EPA described approximately 1.3 million heavy-duty diesel engines overall. The announced aggregate civil penalty was $83.4 million; the more than $1 billion headline also included other programmes and obligations. EPA: 1998 settlement announcement and penalty breakdown; DOJ: 1998 announcement.
- Caterpillar Inc.: $25 million civil penalty.
- Cummins Engine Company: $25 million civil penalty.
- Detroit Diesel Corporation: $12.5 million civil penalty.
- Navistar International Transportation Corporation: $2.9 million civil penalty.
- Mack Trucks and Renault Véhicules Industriels: $13 million jointly; this is one shared amount, not $13 million per company. Renault was a French company.
- Volvo Truck Corporation: $5 million civil penalty. Volvo was a Swedish company.
Company names reflect the EPA announcement at the time; the list includes foreign companies because they were parties to the US settlement. The listed amounts together total $83.4 million and should not be counted again as seven separate $83.4 million penalties.
Cummins: Ram diesel pickups, 2024
In the 2024 US and California settlement, EPA alleged that Cummins installed defeat devices in approximately 630,000 model-year 2013–2019 Ram 2500 and 3500 diesel pickups and installed undisclosed auxiliary emission control devices in approximately 330,000 model-year 2019–2023 pickups. The two groups and allegations are distinct; the latter figure should not be described as a finding that all of those vehicles had illegal defeat devices.
The settlement included a $1.642 billion federal Clean Air Act civil penalty; including California penalties, the announced civil penalties totalled $1.675 billion. Recall and environmental mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Cummins settlement; EPA: case questions and answers.
US diesel aftermarket businesses
These cases concern aftermarket products or sales, rather than original equipment manufacturers' certification. The civil cases below describe allegations and settlements; they do not by themselves establish criminal guilt.
- H&S Performance: EPA announced a proposed 2015 settlement with a $1 million civil penalty, plus a separate $400,000 environmental mitigation project, concerning alleged sales of products that bypassed diesel emissions controls. EPA: H&S Performance.
- Performance Diesel Inc.: a 2019 EPA/DOJ settlement included a $1.1 million civil penalty and restrictions concerning diesel defeat products. EPA: Performance Diesel.
- Xtreme Diesel Performance LLC (XDP): a 2021 settlement included a $1.125 million civil penalty to resolve allegations involving aftermarket defeat devices. EPA: XDP settlement.
- Thoroughbred Performance Products, doing business as Thoroughbred Diesel: EPA announced a $1.25 million civil settlement in 2024 over alleged sales of defeat devices. EPA: Thoroughbred Diesel.
- Sinister Manufacturing Company, doing business as Sinister Diesel: in 2023 the company agreed to plead guilty and to a $500,000 criminal fine and a separate $500,000 civil penalty. Those are distinct components of the announced resolution. DOJ: Sinister Diesel.
- Rudy's Performance Parts Inc.: following its guilty plea, the company was sentenced in 2024 to a $2.4 million criminal fine. Its owner received a separate $600,000 criminal fine. DOJ: Rudy's Performance Parts.
Individuals convicted
Enforcement can also reach individuals. In the Volkswagen case, engineer James Robert Liang pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 40 months in prison and a $200,000 fine. Volkswagen manager Oliver Schmidt pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 84 months in prison and a $400,000 fine. DOJ: United States v. Volkswagen and related defendants.
In the FCA case, engineer Emanuele Palma pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate the Clean Air Act and was sentenced in 2023 to one day of time served. DOJ: United States v. Emanuele Palma.
Other diesel cases in the US market
These cases involved foreign parent companies or multinational groups and US operations. They are included for context and are not labelled as US-headquartered diesel manufacturers.
- Volkswagen AG and affiliates: a 2017 US civil decree imposed $1.45 billion in civil penalties involving environmental and customs claims. This is separate from Volkswagen AG's $2.8 billion criminal fine following its guilty plea, as well as buybacks and other remedies. EPA's diesel cases covered approximately 590,000 US vehicles. EPA: VW civil settlement; EPA: VW violations; EPA: criminal case background.
- FCA US LLC and FCA Italy: a 2019 US and California civil settlement over alleged undisclosed software and excess emissions included a $305 million civil penalty. In a separate criminal case, FCA US LLC was sentenced in 2022 to a $96,145,784 criminal fine and $203,572,892 forfeiture; the approximately $300 million criminal financial sanction was not all a fine. The cases involved model-year 2014–2016 diesel Jeep Grand Cherokee and Ram 1500 vehicles. EPA: 2019 civil settlements; EPA: 2022 criminal sentence.
- Daimler AG and Mercedes-Benz USA LLC: the US civil settlement entered in 2021 involved approximately 250,000 diesel cars and vans and an $875 million civil penalty, including the federal and California portions. Other recall and mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Daimler and Mercedes-Benz settlement.
- Hino Motors Ltd. and US subsidiaries: the 2025 civil resolution concerning false and fabricated emissions-testing data included a $525 million total civil penalty. In a separate criminal case Hino was sentenced to a $521.76 million criminal fine and a $1.087 billion forfeiture judgment. The resolution provides credits for certain other payments, so the figures must not simply be added. EPA: Hino civil settlement summary; EPA: Hino criminal sentence.
These examples illustrate different conduct and legal outcomes. Consult the linked case records for the exact defendants, products, dates, allegations, settlement terms and any later developments.
For a broader list of resolved US cases, see the EPA vehicle and engine enforcement case resolutions. The conduct, legal status and penalties differ by case.
United Kingdom: court findings and owner compensation
Volkswagen Group vehicles with EA189 engines: In April 2020 the High Court of England and Wales found, as a preliminary issue in the VW NOx group litigation, that the software function fitted to the engines was a defeat device. The claim covered owners of Volkswagen, Audi, Škoda and SEAT vehicles. In May 2022 approximately 91,000 claims were settled out of court for £193 million, plus a separate contribution to legal fees and other costs. The settlement was compensation in civil litigation, not a UK regulatory fine; it was made without an admission of liability. The preliminary finding should not be confused with a final judgment on each owner's claim. High Court judgment; Volkswagen annual report: litigation; claimants' solicitors: settlement.
Pan-NOx litigation: In July 2026, the High Court considered strategies in sample diesel vehicles from a number of manufacturers. The court rejected most of the principal allegations but made adverse findings about specific strategies in certain Mercedes-Benz vehicles and Peugeot-Citroën Euro 5 vehicles. This judgment did not decide individual compensation or impose a manufacturer fine. It does not establish that every vehicle or manufacturer named in the litigation had an unlawful device; the proceedings and any appeals need to be checked for subsequent developments. Judiciary of England and Wales: judgment summary, 10 July 2026.
The UK Department for Transport also investigated diesel emissions after the VW disclosure. It found no evidence of the particular VW test-cycle detection used in the other 37 vehicles tested, while reporting differences between laboratory and real-world NOx emissions. That result should not be treated as a finding that every other emissions-control strategy was lawful. Department for Transport: testing programme.
Europe: German diesel-related administrative fines
The German cases below involve administrative offence notices concerning supervisory failures and regulatory deviations. The monetary totals commonly reported include both the sanction and the recovery of economic benefits; they are not all criminal fines or findings that every employee intentionally cheated.
- Volkswagen AG, 2018 — €1 billion: The Braunschweig public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent breach of supervisory duties in connection with diesel engines. It comprised a €5 million sanction and €995 million in recovered economic benefits. Volkswagen accepted the notice. Its scope included EA189 engines worldwide and EA288 Generation 3 engines in the US and Canada; it must not be read as saying all EA288 engines worldwide were covered. Volkswagen Group: notice; 2018 annual report: scope and payment.
- Audi AG, 2018 — €800 million: The Munich II public prosecutor issued an administrative notice for supervision failures concerning regulatory deviations in certain V6/V8 diesel engines and vehicles. The total included €5 million sanction and €795 million recovery of economic benefits. Audi accepted the notice. Volkswagen Group: Audi notice.
- Porsche AG, 2019 — €535 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor's notice concerned negligent supervisory breaches in exhaust-gas testing and regulatory deviations in certain vehicles. The total comprised a €4 million penalty and €531 million recovery of economic benefits. Porsche did not appeal. This notice was for negligent supervision, not a finding that all affected Porsche employees deliberately cheated. Porsche: administrative proceedings.
- Daimler AG (Mercedes-Benz), 2019 — €870 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent supervision in vehicle certification relating to deviations from regulatory requirements in certain vehicles. The total was €4 million sanction and €866 million recovery of economic benefits. Daimler did not challenge the notice, although it maintained objections to separate KBA recall orders. Mercedes-Benz Group: administrative proceedings.
Separate EU competition case: NOx cleaning technology
In 2021 the European Commission fined Volkswagen Group €502,362,000 and BMW €372,827,000 for colluding to restrict competition in technical development of diesel SCR emissions cleaning. Daimler received immunity and no fine after disclosing the cartel; all parties acknowledged participation and settled. This was an antitrust case, distinct from defeat-device investigations: the Commission said it had no indication that the parties coordinated illegal defeat devices and did not determine whether the vehicles complied with emissions standards. The fines must not be presented as penalties for cheating an emissions test. European Commission: decision and fine breakdown.
Revision 7: Emissions Cheating, Defeat Devices and Enforcement Cases
Emissions cheating describes conduct intended to make a vehicle or engine appear compliant while its real-world pollution controls are compromised, or to obtain certification using false information. Cases range from manufacturer software and misleading test data to aftermarket parts sold to disable emissions controls. This page documents selected cases from the United States, the United Kingdom and Europe; it is not a complete list.
See also Petrol and diesel emissions for the systems involved and their normal operation.
Defeat devices and misleading test results
In US vehicle regulation, a defeat device generally includes an element of design that senses operating conditions and reduces an emission control system's effectiveness under conditions reasonably expected in normal operation and use, subject to specific regulatory exceptions. Auxiliary emission control strategies can have legitimate purposes; whether a particular strategy is lawful depends on the applicable regulation, disclosure, certification and facts. An emission-control fault or a difference between laboratory and road measurements is not, by itself, proof of cheating. Rules outside the United States differ. EPA: Cummins frequently asked questions.
In some enforcement cases, regulators alleged that a vehicle behaved differently during certification tests and ordinary driving. Investigators can compare approved test results with independent laboratory testing and on-road portable emissions measurement systems, review diagnostic and certification records, inspect software and components, and investigate sales records. A suspicious measurement calls for further investigation; a legal finding depends on the evidence in the particular case. Volkswagen's case is an example of test recognition alleged by EPA. EPA: Volkswagen violations.
Controls exist to reduce pollutants such as nitrogen oxides (NOx), which contribute to ground-level ozone and particulate pollution. Removing or defeating them can increase pollution even when a vehicle appears to run normally. EPA: ground-level ozone basics.
Reading the enforcement figures
The cases below are selected examples, in US dollars at the amounts announced. A civil settlement generally resolves allegations; it is not itself a criminal conviction or necessarily an admission of liability. A criminal fine follows a criminal case. Civil penalties, criminal fines, forfeiture, recalls, consumer compensation and environmental mitigation are different obligations and should not automatically be added together. A proposed settlement or administrative order is described as such, and an announced amount is not proof of collection.
US heavy-duty diesel manufacturers
1998 heavy-duty diesel settlements
EPA and the US Department of Justice announced settlements with seven diesel engine manufacturers after alleging that engine controls reduced NOx emissions during laboratory certification testing but substantially increased emissions during highway driving. EPA described approximately 1.3 million heavy-duty diesel engines overall. The announced aggregate civil penalty was $83.4 million; the more than $1 billion headline also included other programmes and obligations. EPA: 1998 settlement announcement and penalty breakdown; DOJ: 1998 announcement.
- Caterpillar Inc.: $25 million civil penalty.
- Cummins Engine Company: $25 million civil penalty.
- Detroit Diesel Corporation: $12.5 million civil penalty.
- Navistar International Transportation Corporation: $2.9 million civil penalty.
- Mack Trucks and Renault Véhicules Industriels: $13 million jointly; this is one shared amount, not $13 million per company. Renault was a French company.
- Volvo Truck Corporation: $5 million civil penalty. Volvo was a Swedish company.
Company names reflect the EPA announcement at the time; the list includes foreign companies because they were parties to the US settlement. The listed amounts together total $83.4 million and should not be counted again as seven separate $83.4 million penalties.
Cummins: Ram diesel pickups, 2024
In the 2024 US and California settlement, EPA alleged that Cummins installed defeat devices in approximately 630,000 model-year 2013–2019 Ram 2500 and 3500 diesel pickups and installed undisclosed auxiliary emission control devices in approximately 330,000 model-year 2019–2023 pickups. The two groups and allegations are distinct; the latter figure should not be described as a finding that all of those vehicles had illegal defeat devices.
The settlement included a $1.642 billion federal Clean Air Act civil penalty; including California penalties, the announced civil penalties totalled $1.675 billion. Recall and environmental mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Cummins settlement; EPA: case questions and answers.
US diesel aftermarket businesses
These cases concern aftermarket products or sales, rather than original equipment manufacturers' certification. The civil cases below describe allegations and settlements; they do not by themselves establish criminal guilt.
- H&S Performance: EPA announced a proposed 2015 settlement with a $1 million civil penalty, plus a separate $400,000 environmental mitigation project, concerning alleged sales of products that bypassed diesel emissions controls. EPA: H&S Performance.
- Performance Diesel Inc.: a 2019 EPA/DOJ settlement included a $1.1 million civil penalty and restrictions concerning diesel defeat products. EPA: Performance Diesel.
- Xtreme Diesel Performance LLC (XDP): a 2021 settlement included a $1.125 million civil penalty to resolve allegations involving aftermarket defeat devices. EPA: XDP settlement.
- Thoroughbred Performance Products, doing business as Thoroughbred Diesel: EPA announced a $1.25 million civil settlement in 2024 over alleged sales of defeat devices. EPA: Thoroughbred Diesel.
- Sinister Manufacturing Company, doing business as Sinister Diesel: in 2023 the company agreed to plead guilty and to a $500,000 criminal fine and a separate $500,000 civil penalty. Those are distinct components of the announced resolution. DOJ: Sinister Diesel.
- Rudy's Performance Parts Inc.: following its guilty plea, the company was sentenced in 2024 to a $2.4 million criminal fine. Its owner received a separate $600,000 criminal fine. DOJ: Rudy's Performance Parts.
Individuals convicted
Enforcement can also reach individuals. In the Volkswagen case, engineer James Robert Liang pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 40 months in prison and a $200,000 fine. Volkswagen manager Oliver Schmidt pleaded guilty and was sentenced in 2017 to 84 months in prison and a $400,000 fine. DOJ: United States v. Volkswagen and related defendants.
In the FCA case, engineer Emanuele Palma pleaded guilty to conspiracy to violate the Clean Air Act and was sentenced in 2023 to one day of time served. DOJ: United States v. Emanuele Palma.
Other diesel cases in the US market
These cases involved foreign parent companies or multinational groups and US operations. They are included for context and are not labelled as US-headquartered diesel manufacturers.
- Volkswagen AG and affiliates: a 2017 US civil decree imposed $1.45 billion in civil penalties involving environmental and customs claims. This is separate from Volkswagen AG's $2.8 billion criminal fine following its guilty plea, as well as buybacks and other remedies. EPA's diesel cases covered approximately 590,000 US vehicles. EPA: VW civil settlement; EPA: VW violations; EPA: criminal case background.
- FCA US LLC and FCA Italy: see the detailed Fiat Chrysler diesel emissions scandal page. A 2019 US and California civil settlement over alleged undisclosed software and excess emissions included a $305 million civil penalty. In a separate criminal case, FCA US LLC was sentenced in 2022 to a $96,145,784 criminal fine and $203,572,892 forfeiture; the approximately $300 million criminal financial sanction was not all a fine. The cases involved model-year 2014–2016 diesel Jeep Grand Cherokee and Ram 1500 vehicles. EPA: 2019 civil settlements; EPA: 2022 criminal sentence.
- Daimler AG and Mercedes-Benz USA LLC: see also the detailed Mercedes-Benz diesel emissions scandal page. The US civil settlement entered in 2021 involved approximately 250,000 diesel cars and vans and an $875 million civil penalty, including the federal and California portions. Other recall and mitigation obligations were separate. EPA: Daimler and Mercedes-Benz settlement.
- Hino Motors Ltd. and US subsidiaries: the 2025 civil resolution concerning false and fabricated emissions-testing data included a $525 million total civil penalty. In a separate criminal case Hino was sentenced to a $521.76 million criminal fine and a $1.087 billion forfeiture judgment. The resolution provides credits for certain other payments, so the figures must not simply be added. EPA: Hino civil settlement summary; EPA: Hino criminal sentence.
These examples illustrate different conduct and legal outcomes. Consult the linked case records for the exact defendants, products, dates, allegations, settlement terms and any later developments.
For a broader list of resolved US cases, see the EPA vehicle and engine enforcement case resolutions. The conduct, legal status and penalties differ by case.
For the discovery, affected vehicles, recalls and legal outcomes in the Volkswagen case, see Volkswagen diesel emissions scandal (Dieselgate).
United Kingdom: court findings and owner compensation
Volkswagen Group vehicles with EA189 engines: In April 2020 the High Court of England and Wales found, as a preliminary issue in the VW NOx group litigation, that the software function fitted to the engines was a defeat device. The claim covered owners of Volkswagen, Audi, Škoda and SEAT vehicles. In May 2022 approximately 91,000 claims were settled out of court for £193 million, plus a separate contribution to legal fees and other costs. The settlement was compensation in civil litigation, not a UK regulatory fine; it was made without an admission of liability. The preliminary finding should not be confused with a final judgment on each owner's claim. High Court judgment; Volkswagen annual report: litigation; claimants' solicitors: settlement.
Pan-NOx litigation: In July 2026, the High Court considered strategies in sample diesel vehicles from a number of manufacturers. The court rejected most of the principal allegations but made adverse findings about specific strategies in certain Mercedes-Benz vehicles and Peugeot-Citroën Euro 5 vehicles. This judgment did not decide individual compensation or impose a manufacturer fine. It does not establish that every vehicle or manufacturer named in the litigation had an unlawful device; the proceedings and any appeals need to be checked for subsequent developments. Judiciary of England and Wales: judgment summary, 10 July 2026.
The UK Department for Transport also investigated diesel emissions after the VW disclosure. In the 37 vehicle types tested in the UK, the tests found no evidence of test-cycle manipulation of the kind used by the VW Group by other manufacturers, while reporting differences between laboratory and real-world NOx emissions. That result should not be treated as a finding that every other emissions-control strategy was lawful. Department for Transport: testing programme.
Europe: German diesel-related administrative fines
The German cases below involve administrative offence notices concerning supervisory failures and regulatory deviations. The monetary totals commonly reported include both the sanction and the recovery of economic benefits; they are not all criminal fines or findings that every employee intentionally cheated.
- Volkswagen AG, 2018 — €1 billion: The Braunschweig public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent breach of supervisory duties in connection with diesel engines. It comprised a €5 million sanction and €995 million in recovered economic benefits. Volkswagen accepted the notice. Its scope included EA189 engines worldwide and EA288 Generation 3 engines in the US and Canada; it must not be read as saying all EA288 engines worldwide were covered. Volkswagen Group: notice; 2018 annual report: scope and payment.
- Audi AG, 2018 — €800 million: The Munich II public prosecutor issued an administrative notice for supervision failures concerning regulatory deviations in certain V6/V8 diesel engines and vehicles. The total included €5 million sanction and €795 million recovery of economic benefits. Audi accepted the notice. Volkswagen Group: Audi notice.
- Porsche AG, 2019 — €535 million: The Stuttgart public prosecutor's notice concerned negligent supervisory breaches in exhaust-gas testing and regulatory deviations in certain vehicles. The total comprised a €4 million penalty and €531 million recovery of economic benefits. Porsche did not appeal. This notice was for negligent supervision, not a finding that all affected Porsche employees deliberately cheated. Porsche: administrative proceedings.
- Daimler AG (Mercedes-Benz), 2019 — €870 million: See also the Mercedes-Benz diesel emissions scandal. The Stuttgart public prosecutor issued a notice for negligent supervision in vehicle certification relating to deviations from regulatory requirements in certain vehicles. The total was €4 million sanction and €866 million recovery of economic benefits. Daimler did not challenge the notice, although it maintained objections to separate KBA recall orders. Mercedes-Benz Group: administrative proceedings.
Separate EU competition case: NOx cleaning technology
In 2021 the European Commission fined Volkswagen Group €502,362,000 and BMW €372,827,000 for colluding to restrict competition in technical development of diesel SCR emissions cleaning. Daimler received immunity and no fine after disclosing the cartel; all parties acknowledged participation and settled. This was an antitrust case, distinct from defeat-device investigations: the Commission said it had no indication that the parties coordinated illegal defeat devices and did not determine whether the vehicles complied with emissions standards. The fines must not be presented as penalties for cheating an emissions test. European Commission: decision and fine breakdown.