An engine's moving parts create forces that try to shake it. How well those forces cancel depends on the engine layout and on the weight of the parts fitted. Changing pistons, rods, a crank or a flywheel can change that balance. This page explains the terms. Piston and rod choice is on pistons, connecting rods and rod bolts.
Primary and secondary imbalance
Primary imbalance is vibration at crankshaft speed, and balance is mandatory there. Secondary imbalance is vibration at twice crankshaft speed. It appears in larger straight and V engines with a 180-degree or single-plane crank, where neighbouring pistons reach dead centre together. Even an inline four keeps a net secondary imbalance, because the connecting rod's side-to-side swing makes piston motion non-sinusoidal, so the inertial force at top dead centre can be up to double that at bottom dead centre (Wikipedia: Engine balance).
The layout decides whether cylinder forces cancel. A straight six is balanced in both its reciprocating and rotating planes, a 60-degree V6 has primary imbalances built in, and a flat six has minimal secondary imbalance because opposing cylinders offset each other. Balance shafts, a pair rotating in opposite directions at twice engine speed (Lanchester shafts), are used on engines that cannot cancel the forces otherwise, and V8s usually avoid the problem with a cross-plane crank.
Rotating and reciprocating mass
Parts that move up and down, the pistons and the upper part of each rod, are reciprocating. Parts that spin, the crankshaft, the camshafts and the rod big ends, are rotating. Reciprocating parts cause imbalance when their momentum is not cancelled by an opposing part, and rotating parts cause it through uneven mass distribution, for instance an unbalanced flywheel. Counterweights on the crankshaft offset the weight of the rods and pistons, and the first step of balancing is to weigh and match the pistons and rods.
Internal and external balance
In an internally balanced engine, the crankshaft counterweights are sized to offset the rotating mass of the pistons and rods, and less weight sits on the crank nose. In an externally balanced engine, part of the counterweight sits outside the block, on the damper at the front and the flywheel or flexplate at the rear, because there is no room inside. External balance depends on rod length and overall space (EngineLabs: External Balance).
That has a practical consequence. In an externally balanced engine, the damper and flywheel are part of the balance, so a different weight fitted there leaves the engine out of balance: a damper or flywheel that fits but has the wrong weight does not cancel all vibration, and an engine that needs external balance but lacks it will vibrate badly. The same source notes it puts more load on the crank nose, and that previous owners often mix parts, so the real configuration may not match what the owner assumes. Check the configuration with the engine builder before changing the damper, flywheel or crankshaft.
The harmonic damper
Torsional vibration happens when torque impulses match the shaft's resonant frequency. It cannot be balanced out, only damped, and if the crankshaft cannot be designed to resonate outside the operating range, a damper is fitted. Unchecked, the vibration can cause the crankshaft to fail through fatigue (Wikipedia). The damper's main job is therefore to control torsional vibration. It contributes to primary balance only in an externally balanced engine (EngineLabs). Elastomer dampers cancel vibration in a narrow range, and some designs cover a wider rpm range; use the damper the engine maker or builder specifies, and replace one that is worn or separated.
When to balance
- After fitting new pistons, rods or a crankshaft, ask the machinist whether the assembly is to be balanced, and to what tolerance.
- When raising the rev limit, since out-of-balance forces rise with engine speed: valve springs, valve float and rev limits.
- When changing the flywheel or damper on an externally balanced engine: performance flywheel guide.
- When a new engine vibrates at particular speeds. The source describes one engine with the wrong crank that vibrated at about 1,700 and 2,900 rpm.
Plan balancing as part of the build: planning a performance engine build. Expectations should be realistic; ask the machinist what tolerance is achievable, rather than assuming a figure.
Sources
- Engine balance. Wikipedia. Primary and secondary imbalance, layouts, balance shafts, rotating and reciprocating mass and torsional vibration. Accessed 2026-11-19.
- External Balance: The Curious Case of Counterweight Confusion. Brendan Baker, EngineLabs, 10 May 2022, with Fluidampr. Internal and external balance, damper and flywheel weights and mismatched parts. Accessed 2026-11-19.